Categories: EuropeLegal

Assaulting Freedom to Protect Freedom: UK Government Gets Tough on Press

Edward Snowden

Legislation aimed at preventing acts of terrorism is now being misused to intimidate reporters and the media they work for. In the UK, police authorities invoked Schedule 7 of the Terrorism Act 2000 to question for nine hours David Miranda, the partner of the Guardian columnist who gave voice to US whistle blower Edward Snowden and thus revealed the massive worldwide spying operations of the National Security Agency and its European siblings. At the end of Mr Miranda’s ordeal, police confiscated his laptop computer, memory sticks and other electronic devices. However, they failed to charge him with any offense.

The Terrorism Act was also used to force The Guardian newspaper to destroy computers and hard drives that contained information leaked by Mr Snowden. Even though the UK government was fully aware that copies of the files exist outside the country, it coerced the newspaper to subject the offending hardware to an angle grinder. This ghastly scene unfolded in the basement of the paper’s London office on Saturday, July 20, under the watchful eye of agents from Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ).

One cannot help but wonder what Home Secretary Theresa May thinks she is doing. It’s not the bidding of the US overlords. White House deputy press secretary John Earnest said he simply could not conceive of a situation that would see the American government force journalists to destroy computers and hard drives. Ever holier-than-thou, the White House spokesperson also said Mr Miranda’s detention at Heathrow Airport was not the product of US pressure.

“This ghastly scene unfolded in the basement of the paper’s London office on Saturday, July 20, under the watchful eye of agents from Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ).”

Home Secretary May, who appears to never to have read George Orwell’s dystopian novel 1984, seems bent on repressing all sorts of freedoms and is now asserting the state’s control over its, mostly illegally obtained, secrets. Her misuse of the Terrorism Act beggars belief. By no stretch of the imagination can Mr Miranda be labelled a terrorist or be suspected of aiding and abetting terrorism.

Lord Falconer of Thoroton, the former Labour chancellor who helped write the Terrorism Act, said police had no right to detain Mr Miranda: “Schedule 7 allows for the questioning of somebody to determine whether he or she is preparing, instigating or commissioning terrorism. Clearly Mr Miranda is not such a person.”

Former Conservative Minister of Prisons Crispin Blunt warned that repeatedly misusing police powers brings the laws aimed at countering terrorism in disrepute. Home Secretary May was however not swayed and praised the police for their actions.

So much then for the oft-repeated mantras that the innocent have nothing to fear from the surveillance state or that one can never be too safe. Loyalty is all. Critics of policy merely comfort the enemy. The UK government is quite resourceful when it comes to finding excuses for its heavy-handed attitude.

For the GCHQ officials present at the ceremonial destruction of the laptops and hard drives in Guardian’s basement, things looked rather simple: “You’ve had your fun and now there is no need to write any more on the subject.” Judge, jury and executioner all rolled into two burly agents who are “just doing their job”.

This then is the new reality of contemporary Britain: Any respect for the freedom of expression has gone out the window. Journalists and their newspapers may be intimidated at will. Police powers are broad and go largely unchecked. Of course, all this is to protect society from those that try to undermine its hard-fought freedoms. The irony seems utterly lost on Mrs May and the government she is part of.

CFI

Recent Posts

The Evolution of Elite: A History of Hedge Funds

From Alfred Winslow Jones’s 1949 experiment to today’s trillion-dollar hedge fund industry, the story of…

5 hours ago

The Vanishing Vault: Has Digital Banking Closed More Than Just Branches?

As physical bank branches vanish from high streets across Europe and North America, the shift…

6 days ago

AI Dividends Arrive: Big Tech’s Earnings Surge Shows Power of Scale and Strategy

Meta, Microsoft, Apple, and Amazon deliver robust earnings, reinforcing their central role in markets—and highlighting…

2 weeks ago

Sango Capital: Reframing Africa’s Investment Landscape for a New Global Cycle

As global capital seeks diversified growth and risk-adjusted returns, Sango Capital reaffirms Africa’s position as…

3 weeks ago

The Janus-Faced Banker: Hjalmar Schacht and the Tragedy of German Economics

Hjalmar Schacht, a brilliant economist who rescued Germany from hyperinflation, ultimately became an enabler of…

3 weeks ago

Project Spark: Powering Southern Africa’s Future Through a Balanced Energy Mix

Namibia’s first gas-to-power plant aims to address the region’s chronic energy shortages through a pragmatic,…

4 weeks ago